For your convenience, we’ve built this claims contact information list for the insurance carriers we work with. If a claim should arise after our normal business hours, or should you need immediate assistance, you can use the number to reach your carrier directly. Clicking any of the links below will open the specified carrier’s claim reporting web page.
Carrier
|
Phone
|
Fax
|
Claim Reporting Site
|
A. Central Mutual
|
800.234.6926
|
|
nycm.com
|
Allegany Co-Op
|
877.346.0300 |
585.968.6016 |
alleganygroup.com
|
Amtrust North America
|
888.239.3909 |
866.203.3037 |
amtrustgroup.com |
| Chubb |
800.252.4670 |
800.300.2538 |
chubb.com |
| Cincinnati |
877.242.2544 |
|
cinfin.com |
Dryden Mutual
|
800.782.0154 |
607.257.0624 |
drydenmutual.com |
| Dryden Mutual- After Hours & Weekends |
800.556.5802 |
|
drydenmutual.com |
Erie & Niagara
|
716.632.5433 |
716.632.0410
|
enia.com |
Foremost Insurance Group
|
800.527.3907 |
|
foremost.com |
Genesee Patrons Co-Op
|
585.343.7307 |
585.343.5036 |
gpins.net |
GMAC/National General
|
800.325.1088 |
336.726.2300 |
nationalgrange.com |
Hanover
|
800.682.0250 |
800.399.4734 |
hanover.com |
| Hartford - Business |
800.327.3636 |
800.347.8197 |
thehartford.com |
Hartford - Personal
|
800.243.5860 |
877.536.4765 |
thehartford.com |
| Hartford - Glass Claims only |
877.687.1279 |
|
thehartford.com |
Markel Insurance
|
800.362.7535
|
855.662.7535
|
markelinsurance.com |
Merchants Insurance Group
|
800.952.5246 |
|
merchantsgroup.com |
| Merchants - After Hours |
888.644.6680 |
|
merchantsgroup.com |
National Grange - M SA
|
877.425.2467
|
877.282.3844 |
msagroup.com |
New York Central Mutual
|
888.234.6926 |
607.965.2136 |
nycm.com |
Philadelphia
|
800.765.9749 |
800.685.9238 |
phly.com |
Preferred Mutual
|
800.333.7642
|
607.847.6616 |
preferredmutual.com |
Progressive
|
800.776.4737
|
877.280.5587 |
progressive.com
|
Safeco
|
800.332.3226
|
|
safeco.com
|
Travelers - Business
|
800.238.6225
|
|
travelers.com (IE Only)
|
Travelers - Personal
|
800.252.4633 |
|
travelers.com |
Utica National
|
800.216.1420 |
888.538.2018 |
uticanational.com |